Manage Network Services
Manage the life-cycle of network services.
Last updated
Manage the life-cycle of network services.
Last updated
NSO can also manage the life-cycle for services like VPNs, BGP peers, and ACLs. It is important to understand what is meant by service in this context:
NSO abstracts the device-specific details. The user only needs to enter attributes relevant to the service.
The service instance has configuration data itself that can be represented and manipulated.
A service instance configuration change is applied to all affected devices.
The following are the features that NSO uses to support service configuration:
Service Modeling: Network engineers can model the service attributes and the mapping to device configurations. For example, this means that a network engineer can specify at data-model for VPNs with router interfaces, VLAN ID, VRF, and route distinguisher.
Service Life-cycle: While less sophisticated configuration management systems can only create an initial service instance in the network they do not support changing or deleting a service instance. With NSO you can at any point in time modify service elements like the VLAN id of a VPN and NSO can generate the corresponding changes to the network devices.
Service Instance: The NSO service instance has configuration data that can be represented and manipulated. The service model on run-time updates all NSO northbound interfaces so that a network engineer can view and manipulate the service instance over CLI, WebUI, REST, etc.
References between Service Instances and Device Configuration: NSO maintains references between service instances and device configuration. This means that a VPN instance knows exactly which device configurations it created or modified. Every configuration stored in the CDB is mapped to the service instance that created it.
An example is the best method to illustrate how services are created and used in NSO. As described in the sections about devices and NEDs, it was said that NEDs come in packages. The same is true for services, either if you design the services yourself or use ready-made service applications, it ends up in a package that is loaded into NSO.
Watch a video presentation of this demo on YouTube.
The example examples.ncs/service-provider/mpls-vpn will be used to explain NSO Service Management features. This example illustrates Layer-3 VPNs in a service provider MPLS network. The example network consists of Cisco ASR 9k and Juniper core routers (P and PE) and Cisco IOS-based CE routers. The Layer-3 VPN service configures the CE/PE routers for all endpoints in the VPN with BGP as the CE/PE routing protocol. The layer-2 connectivity between CE and PE routers is expected to be done through a Layer-2 ethernet access network, which is out of scope for this example. The Layer-3 VPN service includes VPN connectivity as well as bandwidth and QOS parameters.
The service configuration only has references to CE devices for the end-points in the VPN. The service mapping logic reads from a simple topology model that is configuration data in NSO, outside the actual service model and derives what other network devices to configure.
The topology information has two parts:
The first part lists connections in the network and is used by the service mapping logic to find out which PE router to configure for an endpoint. The snippets below show the configuration output in the Cisco-style NSO CLI.
The second part lists devices for each role in the network and is in this example only used to dynamically render a network map in the Web UI.
The QOS configuration in service provider networks is complex and often requires a lot of different variations. It is also often desirable to be able to deliver different levels of QOS. This example shows how a QOS policy configuration can be stored in NSO and referenced from VPN service instances. Three different levels of QOS policies are defined; GOLD, SILVER, and BRONZE with different queuing parameters.
Three different traffic classes are also defined with a DSCP value that will be used inside the MPLS core network as well as default rules that will match traffic to a class.
Run the example as follows:
Make sure that you start clean, i.e. no old configuration data is present. If you have been running this or some other example before, make sure to stop any NSO or simulated network nodes (ncs-netsim) that you may have running. Output like 'connection refused (stop)' means no previous NSO was running and DEVICE ce0 connection refused (stop)... no simulated network was running, which is good.
This will set up the environment and start the simulated network.
Before creating a new L3VPN service, we must sync the configuration from all network devices and then enter config mode. (A hint for this complete section is to have the README file from the example and cut and paste the CLI commands).
Add another VPN.
The above sequence showed how NSO can be used to manipulate service abstractions on top of devices. Services can be defined for various purposes such as VPNs, Access Control Lists, firewall rules, etc. Support for services is added to NSO via a corresponding service package.
A service package in NSO comprises two parts:
Service model: the attributes of the service, and input parameters given when creating the service. In this example name, as-number, and end-points.
Mapping: what is the corresponding configuration of the devices when the service is applied. The result of the mapping can be inspected by the commit dry-run outformat native command.
We later show how to define this, for now, assume that the job is done.
When NSO applies services to the network, NSO stores the service configuration along with resulting device configuration changes. This is used as a base for the FASTMAP algorithm which automatically can derive device configuration changes from a service change.
Example 1
Going back to the example L3 VPN above, any part of volvo VPN instance can be modified.
A simple change like changing the as-number on the service results in many changes in the network. NSO does this automatically.
Example 2
Let us look at a more challenging modification.
A common use case is of course to add a new CE device and add that as an end-point to an existing VPN. Below is the sequence to add two new CE devices and add them to the VPNs. (In the CLI snippets below we omit the prompt to enhance readability).
First, we add them to the topology:
Note well that the above just updates NSO local information on topological links. It has no effect on the network. The mapping for the L3 VPN services does a look-up in the topology connections to find the corresponding pe router.
Next, we add them to the VPNs:
Before we send anything to the network, let's look at the device configuration using a dry run. As you can see, both new CE devices are connected to the same PE router, but for different VPN customers.
Finally, commit the configuration to the network
Next, we will show how NSO can be used to check if the service configuration in the network is up to date.
In a new terminal window, we connect directly to the device ce0 which is a Cisco device emulated by the tool ncs-netsim.
We will now reconfigure an edge interface that we previously configured using NSO.
Going back to the terminal with NSO, check the status of the network configuration:
The CLI sequence above performs 3 different comparisons:
Real device configuration versus device configuration copy in NSO CDB.
Expected device configuration from the service perspective and device configuration copy in CDB.
Expected device configuration from the service perspective and real device configuration.
Notice that the service volvo is out of sync with the service configuration. Use the check-sync outformat cli to see what the problem is:
Assume that a network engineer considers the real device configuration to be authoritative:
And then restore the service:
In the same way, as NSO can calculate any service configuration change, it can also automatically delete the device configurations that resulted from creating services:
It is important to understand the two diffs shown above. The first diff as an output to show configuration shows the diff at the service level. The second diff shows the output generated by NSO to clean up the device configurations.
Finally, we commit the changes to delete the service.
Service instances live in the NSO data store as well as a copy of the device configurations. NSO will maintain relationships between these two.
Show the configuration for a service
You can ask NSO to list all devices that are touched by a service and vice versa:
Note that operational mode in the CLI was used above. Every service instance has an operational attribute that is maintained by the transaction manager and shows which device configuration it created. Furthermore, every device configuration has backward pointers to the corresponding service instances:
The reference counter above makes sure that NSO will not delete shared resources until the last service instance is deleted. The context-match search is helpful, it displays the path to all matching configuration items.
As described in Commit Queue, the commit queue can be used to increase the transaction throughput. When the commit queue is for service activation, the services will have states reflecting outstanding commit queue items.
When committing a service using the commit queue in async mode the northbound system can not rely on the service being fully activated in the network when the activation requests return.
We will now commit a VPN service using the commit queue and one device is down.
This service is not provisioned fully in the network, since ce0 was down. It will stay in the queue either until the device starts responding or when an action is taken to remove the service or remove the item. The commit queue can be inspected. As shown below we see that we are waiting for ce0. Inspecting the queue item shows the outstanding configuration.
The commit queue will constantly try to push the configuration towards the devices. The number of retry attempts and at what interval they occur can be configured.
If we start ce0 and inspect the queue, we will see that the queue will finally be empty and that the commit-queue status for the service is empty.
In some scenarios, it makes sense to remove the service configuration from the network but keep the representation of the service in NSO. This is called to un-deploy a service.
To have NSO deploy services across devices, two pieces are needed:
A service model in YANG: the service model shall define the black-box view of a service; which are the input parameters given when creating the service? This YANG model will render an update of all NSO northbound interfaces, for example, the CLI.
Mapping, given the service input parameters, what is the resulting device configuration? This mapping can be defined in templates, code, or a combination of both.
The first step is to generate a skeleton package for a service (for details, see Packages). Create a directory under, for example, ~/my-sim-iossimilar to how it is done for the 1-simulated-cisco-ios/ example. Make sure that you have stopped any running NSO and netsim.
Navigate to the simulated ios directory and create a new package for the VLAN service model:
If the packages folder does not exist yet, such as when you have not run this example before, you will need to invoke the ncs-setup and ncs-netsim create-network commands as described in the 1-simulated-cisco-ios README file.
The next step is to create the template skeleton by using the ncs-make-package utility:
This results in a directory structure:
For now, let's focus on the src/yang/vlan.yang file.
If this is your first exposure to YANG, you can see that the modeling language is very straightforward and easy to understand. See RFC 7950 for more details and examples for YANG. The concept to understand in the above-generated skeleton is that the two lines of uses ncs:service-data and ncs:servicepoint "vlan" tells NSO that this is a service. The ncs:service-data grouping together with the ncs:servicepoint YANG extension provides the common definitions for a service. The two are implemented by the $NCS_DIR/src/ncs/yang/tailf-ncs-services.yang. So if a user wants to create a new VLAN in the network what should be the parameters? - A very simple service model would look like below (modify the src/yang/vlan.yang file):
This simple VLAN service model says:
We give a VLAN a name, for example, net-1, this must also be unique, it is specified as key.
The VLAN has an id from 1 to 4096.
The VLAN is attached to a list of devices and interfaces. To make this example as simple as possible the interface reference is selected by picking the type and then the name as a plain string.
The good thing with NSO is that already at this point you could load the service model to NSO and try if it works well in the CLI etc. Nothing would happen to the devices since we have not defined the mapping, but this is normally the way to iterate a model and test the CLI towards the network engineers.
To build this service model cd to $NCS_DIR/examples.ncs/getting-started/using-ncs/1-simulated-cisco-ios/packages/vlan/src and type make (assuming you have the make build system installed).
Go to the root directory of the simulated-ios example:
Start netsim, NSO, and the CLI:
When starting NSO above we give NSO a parameter to reload all packages so that our newly added vlan package is included. Packages can also be reloaded without restart. At this point we have a service model for VLANs, but no mapping of VLAN to device configurations. This is fine, we can try the service model and see if it makes sense. Create a VLAN service:
Committing service changes does not affect the devices since we have not defined the mapping. The service instance data will just be stored in NSO CDB.
Note that you get tab completion on the devices since they are leafrefs to device names in CDB, the same for interface-type since the types are enumerated in the model. However the interface name is just a string, and you have to type the correct interface name. For service models where there is only one device type like in this simple example, we could have used a reference to the ios interface name according to the IOS model. However that makes the service model dependent on the underlying device types and if another type is added, the service model needs to be updated and this is most often not desired. There are techniques to get tab completion even when the data type is a string, but this is omitted here for simplicity.
Make sure you delete the vlan service instance as above before moving on with the example.
Now it is time to define the mapping from service configuration to actual device configuration. The first step is to understand the actual device configuration. Hard-wire the VLAN towards a device as example. This concrete device configuration is a boilerplate for the mapping, it shows the expected result of applying the service.
The concrete configuration above has the interface and VLAN hard-wired. This is what we now will make into a template instead. It is always recommended to start like the above and create a concrete representation of the configuration the template shall create. Templates are device-configuration where parts of the config are represented as variables. These kinds of templates are represented as XML files. Show the above as XML:
Now, we shall build that template. When the package was created a skeleton XML file was created in packages/vlan/templates/vlan.xml
We need to specify the right path to the devices. In our case, the devices are identified by /device-if/device-name (see the YANG service model).
For each of those devices, we need to add the VLAN and change the specified interface configuration. Copy the XML config from the CLI and replace it with variables:
Walking through the template can give a better idea of how it works. For every /device-if/device-name from the service model do the following:
Add the VLAN to the VLAN list, the tag merge tells the template to merge the data into an existing list (the default is to replace).
For every interface within that device, add the VLAN to the allowed VLANs and set the mode to trunk. The tag nocreate tells the template to not create the named interface if it does not exist
It is important to understand that every path in the template above refers to paths from the service model in vlan.yang.
Request NSO to reload the packages:
Previously we started NCS with a reload package option, the above shows how to do the same without starting and stopping NSO.
We can now create services that will make things happen in the network. (Delete any dummy service from the previous step first). Create a VLAN service:
When working with services in templates, there is a useful debug option for commit which will show the template and XPATH evaluation.
We can change the VLAN service:
It is important to understand what happens above. When the VLAN ID is changed, NSO can calculate the minimal required changes to the configuration. The same situation holds true for changing elements in the configuration or even parameters of those elements. In this way, NSO does not need explicit mapping to define a VLAN change or deletion. NSO does not overwrite a new configuration on the old configuration. Adding an interface to the same service works the same:
To clean up the configuration on the devices, run the delete command as shown below:
To make the VLAN service package complete edit the package-meta-data.xml to reflect the service model purpose. This example showed how to use template-based mapping. NSO also allows for programmatic mapping and also a combination of the two approaches. The latter is very flexible if some logic needs to be attached to the service provisioning that is expressed as templates and the logic applies device agnostic templates.
FASTMAP is the NSO algorithm that renders any service change from the single definition of the create service. As seen above, the template or code only has to define how the service shall be created, NSO is then capable of defining any change from that single definition.
A limitation in the scenarios described so far is that the mapping definition could immediately do its work as a single atomic transaction. This is sometimes not possible. Typical examples are external allocation of resources such as IP addresses from an IPAM, spinning up VMs, and sequencing in general.
Nano services using Reactive FASTMAP handle these scenarios with an executable plan that the system can follow to provision the service. The general idea is to implement the service as several smaller (nano) steps or stages, by using reactive FASTMAP and provide a framework to safely execute actions with side effects.
The example in examples.ncs/development-guide/nano-services/netsim-sshkey implements key generation to files and service deployment of the key to set up network elements and NSO for public key authentication to illustrate this concept. The example is described in more detail in Develop and Deploy a Nano Service.
A very common situation when we wish to deploy NSO in an existing network is that the network already has existing services implemented in the network. These services may have been deployed manually or through another provisioning system. The task is to introduce NSO and import the existing services into NSO. The goal is to use NSO to manage existing services, and to add additional instances of the same service type, using NSO. This is a non-trivial problem since existing services may have been introduced in various ways. Even if the service configuration has been done consistently it resembles the challenges of a general solution for rendering a corresponding C-program from assembler.
One of the prerequisites for this to work is that it is possible to construct a list of the already existing services. Maybe such a list exists in an inventory system, an external database, or maybe just an Excel spreadsheet. It may also be the case that we can:
Import all managed devices into NSO.
Execute a full sync-from on the entire network.
Write a program, using Python/Maapi or Java/Maapi that traverses the entire network configuration and computes the services list.
The first thing we must do when we wish to reconcile existing services is to define the service YANG model. The second thing is to implement the service mapping logic and do it in such a way that given the service input parameters when we run the service code, they would all result in a configuration that is already there in the existing network.
The basic principles for reconciliation are:
Read the device configuration to NSO using the sync-from action. This will get the device configuration that is a result of any existing services as well.
Instantiate the services according to the principles above.
Performing the above actions with the default behavior would not render the correct reference counters since NSO did not create the original configuration. The service activation can be run with dedicated flags to take this into account. See the NSO User Guide for a detailed process.
In many cases, a service activation solution like NSO is deployed in parallel with existing activation solutions. It is then desirable to make sure that NSO does not conflict with the device configuration rendered from the existing solution.
NSO has a commit flag that will restrict the device configuration to not overwrite data that NSO did not create: commit no-overwrite
Some services need to be set up in stages where each stage can consist of setting up some device configuration and then waiting for this configuration to take effect before performing the next stage. In this scenario, each stage must be performed in a separate transaction which is committed separately. Most often an external notification or other event must be detected and trigger the next stage in the service activation.
NSO supports the implementation of such staged services with the use of Reactive FASTMAP patterns in nano services.
From the user's perspective, it is not important how a certain service is implemented. The implementation should not have an impact on how the user creates or modifies a service. However, knowledge about this can be necessary to explain the behavior of a certain service.
In short the life-cycle of an RFM nano service in not only controlled by the direct create/set/delete operations. Instead, there are one or many implicit reactive-re-deploy requests on the service that are triggered by external event detection. If the user examines an RFM service, e.g. using get-modification, the device impact will grow over time after the initial create.
Nano services autonomously will do reactive-re-deploy until all stages of the service are completed. This implies that a nano service normally is not completed when the initial create is committed. For the operator to understand that a nano service has run to completion there must typically be some service-specific operational data that can indicate this.
Plans are introduced to standardize the operational data that can show the progress of the nano service. This gives the user a standardized view of all nano services and can directly answer the question of whether a service instance has run to completion or not.
A plan consists of one or many component entries. Each component consists of two or many state entries where the state can be in status not-reached, reached, or failed. A plan must have a component named self and can have other components with arbitrary names that have meaning for the implementing nano service. A plan component must have a first state named init and a last state named ready. In between init and ready, a plan component can have additional state entries with arbitrary naming.
The purpose of the self component is to describe the main progress of the nano service as a whole. Most importantly the self component last state named ready must have the status reached if and only if the nano service as a whole has been completed. Other arbitrary components as well as states are added to the plan if they have meaning for the specific nano service i.e. more specific progress reporting.
A plan also defines an empty leaf failed which is set if and only if any state in any component has a status set to failed. As such this is an aggregation to make it easy to verify if a RFM service is progressing without problems or not.
The following is an illustration of using the plan to report the progress of a nano service:
Plans were introduced to standardize the operational data that show the progress of reactive fastmap (RFM) nano services. This gives the user a standardized view of all nano services and can answer the question of whether a service instance has run to completion or not. To keep track of the progress of plans, Service Progress Monitoring (SPM) is introduced. The idea with SPM is that time limits are put on the progress of plan states. To do so, a policy and a trigger are needed.
A policy defines what plan components and states need to be in what status for the policy to be true. A policy also defines how long time it can be false without being considered jeopardized and how long time it can be false without being considered violated. Further, it may define an action, that is called in case of a policy being jeopardized, violated, or successful.
A trigger is used to associate a policy with a service and a component.
The following is an illustration of using an SPM to track the progress of an RFM service, in this case, the policy specifies that the self-components ready state must be reached for the policy to be true:
